Cruelty-Free Bark Collars – What’s the Difference?

Posted on

Barking is a specific form of communication that we can’t comprehend. All we know is that excessive barking can be very annoying. Do you also have a dog who just can’t stop barking? You may need to buy an anti-bark collar.

“Aren’t they cruel?” you may ask. Well, it depends. There are many different types of bark collars, and while some look indeed evil, there are also humane bark collars that will not hurt your dog.

How do they work, and what’s the difference between them? Let’s answer these two questions and find a solution to your problem. Below you’ll find some useful information on types and usage of anti-bark collars that will help you decide whether you need to get one for your dog:

dog bark collar

Photo by Lela Gelashvili on Unsplash

Types of bark collars

There are three main types of bark collars. Some of them are humane, but some of them can cause stress and pain in your pup. So what are those types, and how do they work?

The first type of bark collars is the shock collar. This type of collar can lead to stress and anxiety in your dog. Moreover, shock collars can lead to aggressive behavior, and when they malfunction, they might even cause severe burns.

Shock collar detects specific vibrations of a dog’s vocal cords and delivers a low-level electric shock to the dog’s neck before a bark. Many specialists criticize the usage of shock collars and demand to remove this product from the market.

Fortunately, there are cruelty-free collars too. The first type of such collars is a citronella bark collar.

Citronella bark collar has a small microphone that can sense barking. If it detects the barking, collar sprays plant-based citronella fragrance into the air that can stop excessive barking. It’s a painless and stress-free process, so you don’t have to worry about your dog if you get this bark collar.

There’s one problem, though. Citronella bark collars don’t respond to high-pitched barking. You should also avoid it in case you have a few dogs, as every dog barking can trigger a collar’s system.

The other cruel-free collar is the ultrasonic bark collar. As the name suggests, the collar emits ultrasonic sounds that only your dog can hear in response to barking.

Some ultrasonic collars have two types of sounds, one for bad, and one for good behavior. Unfortunately, ultrasonic collars still require more research.

The difference between humane and other bark collars

Now that you know how different types of bark collars work, we can proceed to the next part of the article. What is the difference between them, and what effect can they have on your dog?

When it comes to shock collars, as mentioned before, they can have very negative effects on your dog. They can cause stress and pain, which often leads to aggressive, uncontrollable behaviors.

The citronella bark collars are stress-free and painless, and therefore most specialists recommend them. Recent research has shown that this type of collars doesn’t have any negative effects on dogs.

With ultrasonic collars, the situation is a little bit more complicated. At this point, manufactures are not aware of the long-term consequences of this bark control product. It’s up to dog owners to decide whether using an ultrasonic collar is safe for their four-legged friends.

Should you use bark collars?

dog prone to barking

Photo by Marc Kleen on Unsplash

You already know the types of bark collars, the main differences, and the effects they may have on your dog. So is it okay to use them? The answer is more complicated than you may think.

That’s why, before you decide on buying a bark collar, you should consult a specialist. It’s the first thing you ought to do since bark collars should be used in extreme cases only. Most dogs just need to be trained properly.

As stated above, bark collars can have some negative effects on your dog, especially shock ones. But sometimes, even humane collars like the ones that use citronella may not solve the problem of your dog’s excessive barking.

When the dog notices how and where the collar releases the fragrance, it may bark and take a step back. Some dogs even bark constantly until the can with citronella scent is empty.

Also, keep in mind that bark collars, even the humane ones, are a form of punishment. They can’t help you to find the reason behind your dog’s barking. And if your dog barks because he or she is scared or stressed out, punishing him or her may only intensify fear and anxiety.

That’s why you must go to the veterinarian and dog training firstly. These two things can lead to better results than the usage of bark collar.


It’s understandable why some dog owners decide to use bark collars. Excessive barking can get pretty annoying and problematic. Moreover, many dogs tend to bark in situations where they shouldn’t make a sound.

That’s why it’s essential to train your dog and teach it when it should sit still. That’s the best way to prevent your dog from excessive barking.

Of course, you need to keep in mind that some breeds tend to bark more than others. So if your dog is one of such breeds, you shouldn’t punish it for barking.

Before you decide to purchase your dog an anti-bark collar, you should consult it with the specialist. And if you buy one, make sure that it’s cruelty-free because your fluffy friend deserves the best.

*PIN ME – Cruelty-Free Bark Collars*

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *